d20 – One Of The Best
- The Light – The New Colony
- Merchant on Venice – Rasaka Theatre & Vitalist Theatre
- Tilikum – Sideshow Theatre
- Crumbs From the Table of Joy – Raven Theatre Company
- Small Mouth Sounds – A Red Orchid Theatre
- HeLa – Sideshow Theatre
d12 – Heckuva Good Show
- Les Innocents/The Innocents – (re)discover theatre
- Scandalous: I Want A Banana & Other Desperate Love Stories – Prop Thtr
- Nightmares & Nightcaps: The Stories of John Collier – Black Button Eyes Productions
- The Harvest – Griffin Theatre Company
- Bull in a China Shop – About Face Theatre
- The Good Fight – Babes With Blades Theatre Company
- Yank! A World War II Love Story – Pride Films & Plays
- Through the Elevated Line – Silk Road Rising
d10 – Worth Going To
- Neverland – Prop Thtr
- Eclipsed – Pegasus Theatre Chicago
- Grand Guignol: Bad Milk – iO Theater
- Neverwhere – Lifeline Theatre
- Hamlet – The Gift Theatre
- Damascus – Strawdog Theatre Company
- L’Imitation of Life – Hell in a Handbag Productions
- 9 to 5 The Musical – Firebrand Theatre
- Kingdom – Broken Nose Theatre
- Nice Girl – Raven Theatre
- We’re Gonna Be Okay – American Theater Company
- Rose – Greenhouse Theater Center
d8 – Not Bad, Not Great
- Hooded, Or Being Black for Dummies – First Floor Theater
- The Revolutionists – Organic Theater Company
- Bunny Bunny: Gilda Radner, A Sort Of Love Story – Mercury Theater
- The Madwoman of Chaillot – Promethean Theatre Ensemble
- Hatfield & McCoy – The House Theatre of Chicago
d6 – Has Some Merit
- No shows in this category for 2018!
d4 – Not Worth The Time
- No shows in this category for 2018!